Categories
2000 - 2007 Booker Prize Historical Fiction Orange Prize Other Prizes

The Siege – Helen Dunmore

 

Short listed for 2001 Orange Prize and Whitbread Novel of the Year Award

In September 1941 German troops surrounded the city of Leningrad, cutting off all supply routes. This left the 3 millions residents battling for survival – most so hungry that they resorted to making soup from strips of leather. 

The Siege is historical fiction at its best. The writing was so vivid that I almost felt as though I’d been there.

Late in the morning a lilac-coloured dawn will come, with burning frost that glitters on branches, on spills of frozen water, on snow, cupolas and boarded up statues. Nothing has ever been more beautiful than these broad avenues, the snow-coloured Neva, the parks and embankments. Only the people mar its perfection as they crawl out of their homes into the radiance of snow. Perhaps today is the day when they’ll fail to reach the bread queue. So they move on, flies caught between sheets of glass.

The book focused on one family. This personal insight into the crisis made the events come alive. I felt a deep connection to each member of the family and I willed them all to survive.

The Siege also contained a few chapters from the view-point of Pavlov, the nutritionist controlling the amount of food that each person received with their ration card each day. This was a fantastic addition to the plot as it allowed the real facts and figures of the situation to be revealed to the reader. It also allowed us to learn about the numerous ways in which the citizens were advised get nutrition from objects they possessed in their homes – some much more unusual than others.

As you can imagine this could never be described as a happy book, but I can only admire the strength of human spirit – that desire to survive despite the odds being stacked against them.

Highly recommended.

The Siege is the prequel to the 2010 Booker long listed The Betrayal. If you haven’t read The Siege then I highly recommend that you avoid reading any reviews for The Betrayal – I discovered that my 2010 Booker research had led me to reading a few spoilers for The Siege.

The Siege is my first experience of Helen Dunmore’s writing, but I’m a convert! I hope to read The Betrayal next week, but will also be on the look out for all her other books.

Have you read any Helen Dunmore books?

Which one is your favourite?

 

56 replies on “The Siege – Helen Dunmore”

Jessica, If your husband reads a lot of non-fiction then he might already know most of the facts in this book, but if he likes a good story then he’d probably still find a lot to enjoy.

I’m really intrigued by this book since I find Russian history fascinating. I also like the description of St. Petersburg from that excerpt; it brings back memories, even though I was never there in winter. I think The Siege will be making it onto my list of books to read soon.

Mome Rath, It is quite rare to find such vivid descriptions in historical fiction. Some people might find it a bit excessive, but I loved it. The atmosphere was incredible. I hope that you enjoy The Siege :-)

Hi Jackie,
I read Zennor in Darkness a fictional exploration of DH Lawrence’s time in Cornwall, by Helen Dunmore and I think she is ‘Booker’ standard.

Joanna, I know what you mean. She has an amazing talent. The book made me feel so hungry and then I felt guilty for eating while reading about all those people starving. :-(

Helen Dunmore is an amazing writer, with a huge scope for subject and style, every one of her books that I’ve read has been fantastic and I cannot recommend her enough. Mourning Ruby has to be mt favourite in that its so sad, but Your Blue Eyed Boy is spooky as anything. And if you want to read her stuff then you can’t bet better value that this http://www.thebookpeople.co.uk/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/qs_product_tbp?storeId=10001&catalogId=10051&langId=100&productId=174886 ten books for a tenner from t’book people

I read this a few years ago and found it paled in comparison to my favourite book with this setting. Looking back though, I think that I may have been a bit harsh because of that comparison.

I had no idea that The Betrayal was a follow up to this book. I think I am going to have to go and find out more about it.

Marg, I’d love to know which book was better. Please let me know so that I can ensure I read it :-)

I hope that you enjoy The Betrayal if you decide to read it.

Like you, I loved The Siege. I actually used it in my masters dissertatation on Soviet Russia at this time as an example of how literature can do more to bring alive a complex situation than non-fiction alone. I remember the scene with the last pot of jam everytime anyone talks about jam and it still makes me salivate a little.

Thanks for the review. I look forward to reading you thoughts on The Betrayal soon. (Am awaiting my Birthday on Sunday and hopefully a copy of The Betrayal will be waiting for me at the breakfast table!)

Sam, The Siege is the perfect example for a dissertation. I can’t imagine any non fiction book having the same impact – it is that personal take on the story that makes it so much more powerful. I found the jam scene very emotional too – tt is amazing how much pleasure they gained from a single spoonful of it.

Happy Birthday for Sunday – I hope you get your copy of The Betrayal :-)

I read this a couple of years ago and found it utterly compelling. So much so that I found it hard to do the weekly shop – it made me ealise how much we have and how much we take for grnted. Can’t wait to read The Betrayal – you just reminded me how good The Siege was.

Carrie, I’m sure that The Betrayal can be understood without reading The Siege, but I think that you’d never be able to enjoy The Siege as much if it wasn’t read first.

I hope that you enjoy both books. :-)

Thanks for the warning about the spoilers in info about The Betrayal.
I have had a copy of The Siege for years but have not got round to reading it, probably not helped by it being on a difficult to access high shelf in my bookroom/office.
Your review means that I will go home and find a stepladder so I can put it at the top of my TBR mountain.

Amy, It was very interesting to hear from the nutritionist. Without his appearance I might have assumed that those in control didn’t care about the public and left them to die, but they were actually doing the best they could with very limited resources. Fascinating stuff.

sounds very good Jackie ,I d recomend Elise Blackwell’s hunger it is also set in Stalingrad ,alaways a rich vein for fiction beinoff city of theives also set there ,all the best stu

Stu, Books set in Russia do seem to have fantastic plots. I haven’t read either of the books that you mention, but I’ve added them to my wishlist now. Thanks for the recommendations.

Hello Jackie, it’s been a while since I commented but I’m still following your blog.

I agree with you, and with the many others here who are full of praise for The Siege. I too found it a very impressive piece of historical fiction. More recently I read a very different Dunmore book called With Your Crooked Heart, and found it very unappealling. It is fortunate I read The Siege first, because without having that experience behind me, Crooked Heart would probably have put me off this author for good. The latter is set in modern Britain and features some rather unlikeable characters in failing relationships. Even though I read it earlier this year, that is about all I can remember of it.

Dunmore is clearly a versatile writer who ranges widely in her topics, settings and character types. If that means an individual reader reacts very differently to some of her titles, then that is probably no bad thing. Anyone who likes the sound of both these books may be interested to know that The Book People are selling a set of ten of her paperbacks for £9.99 (excluding postage).

David, Thanks for the warning about the differences in Dunmores books. It seems that a lot of talented writers like to stretch themselves and write very different things. I don’t think I’ll ever be put of trying her books now, but I will lower my expectations when trying some of her other books.

Thanks for the Book People info – BookElfLeeds had already pointed that out to me. Now I’m just trying to work out what else I should buy to get free delivery :-)

Apologies to BookElf for failing to notice that.

You could perhaps get something for your offspring, since TBP have a lot of children’s books? Failing that, I can certainly recommend the Robert Goddard three book set. He writes plot-rich fiction with plenty of twists and turns.

David, I’m tempted by the classic crime collection and will probably get the Winnie the Witch set for my boys, but I still need to spend some more – I do love book shopping :-)

I haven’t read any Goddard, but my Dad enjoys his books. I’ll have to borrow one of his sometime :-)

I’m not a big historical fiction reader, but I think this one would be perfect for me. I love the time period, and I love the perspective that it gives. I think you are personally responsible for about half my TBR list girl.

This sounds really good. I don’t think that there’s enough literature and movies about the Russians during World War II. I think that’s probably because so many Russians died that they don’t really like to talk about it.

I never heard of this book or author before so thanks for reviewing it. Sounds like a must read for me! I love books set in WWII and also books set in Russia during this time.

Dear Jackie,

Please stop!! I can no longer afford to support my reading habit since I discovered your blog. Ninety percent of the books you have reviewed on your site have gone directly onto my to-be-bought list. Here today is yet another one. I must put my foot down somewhere. I simply cannot afford all these books. If you do not cease with these ingenious reviews and begin reviewing at least a few books that are complete rubbish, I am going to have to consider sending you a bill.

Yours only half jokingly,

Robbie

Robert, LOL! It is great to hear it. I’m afraid that I have gone through a run of amazing books recently. Luckily for you I have a few average/terrible books waiting to be reviewed so your bank balance should be safe for at least a week ;-)

I just finished this one too and like you just loved it. Such simple but brilliant writing in many ways – I felt hungry while I was reading this book my empathy for the characters was so strong. I have just collected The Betrayal from the library tonight and am eager to start it but I”m also sad that I will have nothing good to read after I finish it!!

Karen, It is great to hear that you enjoyed it too :-) I know what you mean about great book syndrome – luckily I’ve had a run of fantastic books recently, but I do wonder what will be good once I’ve finished The Betrayal. Hopefully one of the other Bookers will be a surprise gem.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.