Three Mini Reviews

The BookDepository

Benediction (Plainsong 3)

Benediction by Kent Haruf

Five words from the blurb: Colorado, heart-break, friendship, ordinary, humanity

Benediction is a quiet novel about ordinary people living in a small town in Colorado. The book focuses on Dad Lewis, a man dying of cancer. It shows how his friends and family cope with this situation and forces the reader to look at life in a slightly different way.

I normally complain about books being too quiet (see my thoughts on Harvest below!) but Haruf has a way of making the most ordinary scenes zing with life. The thoughts of everyone involved are explained with such compassion that it is hard not to become emotionally invested in everything that happens.

She imagined his arrival at home, his wife’s worry and complaint, and his consoling her, joking a little, making his excuses and explanations, and she could see them then in the familiar pretty picture walking arm in arm, looking in at the sleeping children, and entering their own bedroom, lying in bed with her head resting on his shoulder and her hair spread out like a fan, and then she saw him kissing her and doing what he had just done with her, and she realized she was crying again and after a while she got up and went into the old tiled bathroom to rinse her face.

I haven’t read Plainsong or Eventide and that might help to explain why I wasn’t as excited about this book as others have been, but Haruf’s writing impressed me so much that I will be reading all of his books at some point in the future.

Recommended to everyone who enjoys literary fiction.


Harvest Longlisted for 2013 Booker Prize

Harvest by Jim Crace

Five words from the blurb: village, outsiders, threat, communities, suspicion

Harvest is set in a small English village about 250 years ago. It is an atmospheric piece of historical fiction that looks at how a rural community is affected by the arrival of three strangers.

The writing was vivid and wonderful descriptions allow the reader to picture exactly what life was like all those years ago.

He was a pleasant man, I’d say. No more than thirty years of age and dressed much like the master, not for labour but for the open air, in sturdy boots, breeches, a jerkin, and a plain cap without feather, brooch or badge. His beard was shaped and honed to a point with wax, I have a narrow trowel that matches it. A townsman’s beard. A wealthy beard. And he was lop-sided when he moved, with a stiff arm and shoulder on his left

The style was chatty and friendly so it was easy to warm to Walter, the central character. The passionate way the story was narrated also helped to alleviate some of the darkness in the subject matter.

But, despite the many merits of this book, I didn’t fall in love with it. The plot was too meandering and slow and the story was too ordinary to excite me. I finished the book because it was quite short, but it failed to teach me anything new and I don’t think I’ll be rushing to try any of Crace’s other books.

If you enjoy simply being transported to different historical time periods then you’ll love this book, but I prefer plots that are a bit more exciting.


The Spinning Heart Longlisted for 2013 Booker Prize

The Spinning Heart by Donal Ryan

Five words from the blurb: Ireland, financial, collapse, tensions, generation

The Spinning Heart shows the effect that Ireland’s financial collapse has on a series of ordinary people. Each chapter is narrated by a different character so the reader sees a range of perspectives.

The writing was excellent and the Irish dialect was (to my untrained ears) perfectly deployed.

…the day we buried her I wanted to scream at her to come back, come back, we’ll walk to the shop and I’ll hold your hand and we won’t mind Daddy and I’ll pick a bunch of flowers and leave them on your locker for you and if he calls me a pansy we’ll tell him to feck off and we’ll give back all these years of aging and dying, stupid silence and be Mammy and Bobby again, two great auld pals.

Unfortunately I’m not a fan of short stories. The Spinning Heart is a very short book and I don’t think that a book this length can justify having 21 different narrators. Some characters reappeared, but overall it felt disjointed and am not convinced it can be described as a novel.

If you enjoy short stories then I’m sure you’ll love this book, but it wasn’t for me.


Send to Kindle


  1. cbjames says:

    I’m glad to see you are reviewing so many l long list books. I’ve not read these but I did read two other books by Grace and enjoyed them both. I didn’t “love” either though.

    1. Jackie says:

      cbjames, Crace is an entertaining writer. I can see why people enjoy his books, but I can’t see myself really loving one either. Shame :-(

  2. Quiet books work for me or not purely depending on my mood. Right now I’m not in the mood for quiet, but I think Harvest could work nicely for me at another time.

    1. Jackie says:

      Andi, I look forward to hearing what you think of it another time.

  3. Sandy says:

    I think I read a book by Crace awhile back called “The Pest House” about the world after a disease wipes out everyone. I liked it. Wasn’t my favorite of all time but definitely atmospheric and well-written.

    1. Jackie says:

      Sandy, Crace is great at doing atmospheric. ‘Pest House’ appeals to me a lot more – it sounds a bit like Blindness. But for that reason it probably isn’t one I’ll pick up. Blindness was perfection and it will be very hard for another book to live up to it.

  4. Out of these, I’ve only read benediction, but liked it a lot. Glad u did as well.

  5. Shan says:

    I felt the same way about Harvest.

  6. I haven’t read any of these yet, but I do fancy tring The Spinning Heart, although that does sound an awful lot of narrators!

  7. kimbofo says:

    Glad to see your thoughts on The Spinning Heart — I agree with them entirely. I read this earlier in the year but just could not muster the enthusiasm to write a review. I was really disappointed by the book and I just can’t understand the lavish praise it’s received. I didn’t have a problem with the huge number of narrators, but I did have a problem in that their voices all sounded the same!

    Please to hear you liked Benediction, too. I still haven’t read my copy yet. I read Plainsong and Eventide and ADORED them both.

Leave a Reply