We – Yevgeny Zamyatin

The BookDepository

 Translated from the Russian by Clarence Brown

Five words from the blurb: dystopia, totalitarian, masterpiece, individual, freedom

I hadn’t heard of this book until Michelle recommended it on my Literary Science Fiction post, but I’m so pleased that she bought it to my attention as I feel it is one of the most important dystopian fiction novels ever written.

We was originally written in 1921, but was suppressed in Russia and so first published in English, French and Czech, before finally being published in Russian in 1988. We is recognised to have been the inspiration behind George Orwell’s classic 1984, but on reading it I spotted key ideas that I’d read in many other books.

The plot follows D-503 (everyone is given a unique number, not a name) who lives in a totalitarian society built entierly from glass (so they can be spied on more easily). All aspects of life are controlled to the extent that everyone must get up, work and eat at exactly the same times each day. D-503 begins to have dreams and question the society he lives in. Everything changes when he discovers that there are other humans living outside OneState – haired humans who live free amongst the animals….

The book is very readable and hasn’t dated at all. It is amazing to think that it was written 90 years ago as most of the ideas and fears still hold true for us today. The book was packed with thought-provoking quotes: 

But, my dear readers, you’ll have to do just a little thinking. It helps a lot. Because, you know, all human history, as far back as we know it, is the history of moving from nomadic life to a more settled way of life. So, doesn’t it follow that the most settled form of life (ours) is by the same token the most perfect form of life (ours)?  If people used to wander over the earth from one end to the other, that only happened in prehistoric times, when there were nations and wars and trade discoveries of this and that America. But why do it now? Who needs it?

I was gripped throughout, but have to admit that a few things went over my head. I would have benefited from having a reading guide to explain some of the weirder sections, but I’m sure this is one of those books that gets better with each re-reading.

The only problem with this book was that I didn’t develop an emotional attachment to any of the characters. I was interested to see what would happen to them, but didn’t really care about their fate.

I think it is important for anyone interested in dystopian fiction to read this book, but if you after an emotional response to events then you need to look elsewhere.

The thoughts of other bloggers:

I’m glad I read We for the historical and contextual value as a dystopia, but I didn’t love it. Rebecca Reads

….the longer We went on, the more it reminded me of The Famished Road by Ben Okri with its endless blending of colour and dream. Books, Time, and Silence

…one of the weirdest, most disorienting things I’ve ever read. The Zen Leaf


Send to Kindle

52 Comments

  1. Mome Rath says:

    Thanks for reminding me of this book. It’s been recommended to me before, and I still haven’t read it. I’ll have to move it higher up the list to read.

    1. I always forget about books like this too. I’m making an effort to make a note of them and ensure I try to read them now. I hope you enjoy it when you get to it.

  2. Annabel says:

    This one is in my pile, and will get promoted as soon as I can find it! I’m trying to make an effort to read more of the books that have influenced more modern writers (not necessarily 19thC classics) and this is one of them that I must read as a fan of dystopian novels.

    1. Jackie says:

      Annabel, Me too. I often struggle to enjoy the older classics, but it is nice to read those more modern books which have been a big influence too. My only problem is that I often don’t know which ones they are – hopefully I’ll find out gradually.

  3. JoV says:

    I haven’t heard of this book. Thanks for introducing this one to me. Any time for a dystopia read. :)

    1. Jackie says:

      Jo, Great news! I hope you enjoy it.

  4. Tim Jones says:

    It’s good to see “We” getting this recognition – it tends to live in the shadow of “1984”, even though it preceded Orwell’s novel.

    I can also highly recommend Zamyatin’s short story collection “The Dragon and Other Stories”, set in the cheerless years immediately following the Russian Revolution – in fact, I enjoyed this collection more than “We”, and it has some of the emotional connection “We” lacks.

    1. Jackie says:

      Tim Jones, I agree it is sad that few people know about this book. I was made to study 1984 in school and We was never even mentioned. I think We is the much better book, having none of those long, dull ‘book within a book’ sections. Hopefully more people will be made aware of it in future.

  5. This is an ebook that’s on my list for this year. I’m glad you enjoyed it so much. I’m looking forward to it.

    1. Jackie says:

      Judith, I’ll be interested to see what you make of it. I’m sure you’ll recognise a lot of scenes in other books you’ve read.

  6. cbjames says:

    I just got this book last month. I heard an intriguing review on a favorite podcast of mine. I’ll be reading it as soon as I’m done with the TBR Dare in April.

    1. Jackie says:

      cbjames, It is a shame that you don’t already have a copy lurking in your TBR pile. It is an intriguing little book and I hope you like it.

  7. Alex Baugh says:

    I never heard of this book, but thanks for bringing it to my attention. When I started reading, the first thing I thought of was the old Fritz Lang film Metropolis, even though they are somewhat different.
    Sounds like an interesting book.

    1. Jackie says:

      Alex, I haven’t heard of Metropolis so I’m afraid I can’t compare the two for you, but I will look up Metropolis as if it is anything like this book then I want to watch it!

  8. Amanda says:

    This is one of those books that has just stuck with me even though I was unsure of it at the time. I’m hoping to get to reread it one of these days!

    1. Jackie says:

      Amanda, I can see it being the same for me too. I’m sure that in a few months I’ll have forgotten about the weird bits and only remember those vivid scenes. I hope your rereading experience is a good one.

  9. Glad you liked it, Jackie!! It is a shame more people don’t know about it.

    1. Jackie says:

      Michelle, Hopefully I’ll be able to let a few people know that it exists :-)

  10. Alex says:

    Glad to see you’re well on your way to reading only 4 starts and above :)

    1. Jackie says:

      Alex, I’m trying! I ruthlessly abandoned another book just 5 minutes ago ;-)

  11. Excellent review! I want to read this book now. How does this book compare to Brave New World?

    1. Jackie says:

      Donovan, I’m afraid I haven’t read Brave New World yet – it is very high on my priority list, so hopefully I’ll be able to answer that question for you in a month or two.

  12. Sandy says:

    If you haven’t already, you should link this up over at Lenore’s as she is having Dystopian February over at her place! This sounds like it is the mother of the dystopian novel. And a decent translation it looks like.

    1. Jackie says:

      Sandy, Thanks for the reminder about Lenore’s Feb. I’ll go and add the link later.

      I think the translation is very good. It never felt Russian and could easily have been set/written in any country/language.

  13. Brenna says:

    This sounds amazing. I just added it to my TBR. Thanks for bringing it to my attention!

    1. Jackie says:

      Brenna, I hope that you enjoy reading it. :-)

  14. Amy says:

    I hadn’t heard of this one before, sounds really interesting for sure.

    1. Jackie says:

      Amy, I’m pleased that I was able to bring it to your attention. :-)

  15. I feel as though I should have heard of this novel. It does sound interesting, but it also sounds like something I’d rather see the film version of than read the book. I do still need to make my through some of your other literary science fiction recommendations though!

    1. Jackie says:

      Carrie, I’m not sure that it would work well on film. I think the beauty is in the ideas raised and they wouldn’t be as powerful on screen – there isn’t enough action for a good film to be produced. I agree that this might not be the best place to start a journey into science fiction though – perhaps once you’ve read a few different ones you might be tempted to give We a try.

      1. I think the movie Equilibrium starring Christian Bale was heavily influenced by this book, though. It’s great!

        1. Jackie says:

          I haven’t seen that either :-( I don’t watch many films …..

  16. I love the sound of this book! I MUST get me a copy – SOON!!!

    1. Jackie says:

      The Book Whisperer, I love enthusiastic responses like that!

  17. stujallen says:

    I like other haven’t read this but was vaguely aware ,didn’t realise the orwell connection love orwell so will be read this soon is well some point this year ,all the best stu

    1. Jackie says:

      Stu, If you are a big fan of Orwell then I’m sure you’ll love this. Enjoy :-)

  18. Andi says:

    I was about halfway through this book and enjoying it very much when I LOST IT. Couldn’t be more upset with myself. It’s got to be around here somewhere.

    1. Jackie says:

      Andi, Oh no! I hope you uncover it soon.

  19. Christina says:

    I read this book last year for my Political Science Fiction class and just could not get into it. Everybody else in my class seemed to love it so I guess I missed something. Or maybe, like you, I was never able to develop an emotional attachment to the characters. Obviously, it bother me more than you.

    1. Jackie says:

      Christina, This is the sort of book that I wish I had read in a class as I’m sure you gain so much from being told things about it that straight reading would miss. Perhaps looking into it too closely spoiled the magic for you? Nevermind – we can’t like them all. :-)

  20. She says:

    I’ve never heard of this one! I’m very intrigued now especially with it being written by a Russian author– I don’t think I’ve ever read a Russian dystopian!

    1. Jackie says:

      She, If you are after a Russian dystopian then you might be dissapointed as it doesn’t feel at all Russian, but I’m sure that doesn’t matter – it is wonderful anyway :-)

  21. Tomcat says:

    this is one of those books that I’ve been meaning to read for years and years, but somehow I still haven’t bothered. I think I will now.

    1. Jackie says:

      Tomcat, This is one of the rare occasions where I read it as soon as I heard of it. I hope that you enjoy it after waiting so many years.

  22. Steph says:

    This sounds AMAZING. I LOVE dystopian fiction and have been thinking I should re-read 1984 at some point this year, but now I am chomping at the bit to get my hands on this instead. I think this could be another title that gets me back to thinking more favorably about Russian authors…

    1. Jackie says:

      Steph, It is well worth reading this instead of a 1984 re-read. I think you will love it and I’m sure it will persuade you that some Russian authors are wonderful :-)

  23. We has been on my wish-list for some time and I’ve especially been wanting to read it after re-reading Nineteen Eighty-Four. Hopefully this year.
    What I love about dystopian (or is it dystopic?) literature is how there are often so many nods to other books in the genre, that each books builds upon the others.
    With the dream sequences, it sounds as if We brings in some magical realism.

    1. Jackie says:

      Claire, Sorry – I replied to this comment ages ago, but it must not have gone through :-(

      I think that you will enjoy reading this one – there are sections of magical realism for you to enjoy and the number of dystopian influences is impressive. It is sad that so few people know about it.

  24. Kathleen says:

    It is so amazing that this book was written 90 years ago. It sounds brilliant!

    1. Jackie says:

      Kathleen, …and there is no way of knowing its age from reading it – it was way ahead of its time.

  25. Glad to hear you enjoyed it! This was on the reading list for an elective course I took several years ago on Classic Sci Fi and Fantasy and I was thrilled with it. It’s one of those that I pick up whenever I see an “extra” copy in second-hand shops (I’m sure you have those books too), but I’m definitely due for a re-read.

    1. Jackie says:

      BuriedInPrint, I have a lot of books like that!! I’m surprised you find many copies of this one though – I wouldn’t have thought many made it into the second hand shops! It is good that you got to study it – I think there were a lot of references I’ll have missed and I’m sure a class would make me appreicate its brilliance even more.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. February Summary and Plans for March – Farm Lane Books Blog

Leave a Reply