Categories
Uncategorized

The Picture of Dorian Gray – Oscar Wilde

The Picture of Dorian Gray is one of those classics that I always felt I should have read, but for some reason I hadn’t got round to it. It wasn’t until I started reading the book that I appreciated how much it has crept into our society – the pages were packed with quotes that I recognised.

Dorian Gray is a vain young man enjoying the pleasures of high society. One day an artist paints his portrait and Dorian realises that his good looks will not last forever. Desperate to retain his youth Dorian exchanges his soul for an assurance that the portrait will age rather than himself. Unfortunately other people get a bit suspicious when he doesn’t age and so Dorian starts to experience a few problems!

I never know what to expect from these classics, but I was impressed by how readable The Picture of Dorian Gray was. It had a light, almost humorous tone and I was quickly drawn into Dorian’s life.  I loved discovering all the quotes that I already knew and the countless bits of wisdom:

‘Yes,’ he continued, ‘that is one of the great secrets of life. Nowadays most people die of a sort of creeping common sense, and discover too late that the only things one never regrets are one’s mistakes.’

I lost interest slightly in the middle section, but the plot picked up again towards the end. I thought the ending, although predictable, was very good.

Recommended, if only so you can appreciate how many quotes from this book we use in everyday life.

I also watched the DVD as part of C.B. James’ Read The Book, See the Movie Challenge

Dorian Gray DVD

The DVD had a very different feel to the book. The film was dark and menacing, so the charm of the book was lost under this evil sense of foreboding. Most of the wonderful quotes were not included and so the majority of the things I enjoyed about the book were missing.

The film did benefit from some great Victorian costumes and sets, but spotting some tarmac road ruined the atmosphere a bit for me!

I can’t fault the acting, but some of the casting was a bit dubious. The actors didn’t match up to the pictures I’d built in my head when reading the book – especially Rachel Hurd-Wood. This wasn’t a major problem, overall the actors were probably the best thing about this film.

My main problem was with the ending – it was far too dramatic. Sometimes it is best to leave things to the imagination, but the film showed us everything. It was needless action for the sake of trying to attract a different audience to the film.

Overall I’d say that this is one of those films that just shouldn’t have been made. Some books just don’t work on the big screen.

Have you read The Picture of Dorian Gray?

What did you think of the film?

59 replies on “The Picture of Dorian Gray – Oscar Wilde”

I loved this book – the wit, the humor, the character development, and of course, the story!

For some reason though, I’ve not read anything else by Oscar Wilde. I really should change that.

Glad you enjoyed the book – it’s one of those classics which I think almost everyone likes.

anothercookiecrumbles, I think this is Oscar Wilde’s only novel. I’ve never read a play before, but perhaps I should start with one of his – I do love his style :-)

Dorian Gray is one of those books that I still need to read. I’ve tried to read it twice, but got distracted 30 pages in and didn’t continue after that. I have told myself for years that this is the one classic I need to read this year. I wonder if I’ll finally manage to do so this year?

I havent read the book but I agree completely about the film. I liked the guy who played Dorian and I thought Colin Firth was brilliant but other than that I thought it dragged on and on and I was glad when it finished.

Jessica, At first I thought the actor who played Dorian was the wrong choice, but I warmed to him over the length of the film. I thought they all acted well – it was everything else that was wrong!

I don’t have any inclination to watch the film, even though Colin Firth is in it and I do love Colin Firth.

I love Oscar Wilde’s style and have read some of his short stories and plays. Even though I was not a fan of The Children’s Book, I really enjoyed the Wilde cameo.

Claire, It is a good film to play ‘watch for the inconsitencies’ with. Get a few friends round and have a good giggle about all the things it gets wrong!!

I didn’t really know enough about Oscar Wilde to appreciate the cameo in The Children’s Book. I’ll hopefully get more out of those references in the future.

I’ve been wanting to read this book for ages! I have it on my shelf. The new movie has been pushing me even more lately. (definitely will watch the movie only after reading the book) So, soon I hope. Great to hear that it’s readable and witty. I think I will like it.

I’ve always wanted to read this book, but feel that watching the film last year may have ruined it for me! I thought the film was terrible (like you mentioned a bit, way too dramatic, with some dubious special effects!). So I might need to wait a while before getting back to the book.

Lija, The good news is that the film doesn’t have much in common with the book. I’d say you could easily read it now without feeling as though the film had spoiled it. The plot is quite different and the writing quality takes it to a whole other level :-)

I loved the book but I haven’t seen this new version. Despite your misgivings about the film I think I need to see it.

There is an old film of Dorian Gray (with Angela Lansbury) where everything except for the portrait is in black and white. Although not entirely true to the novel, the film is worth a look.

Thomas at My Porch, Thanks for letting me know about the old film – I’ll have to ensure I watch it at some point.

I know what you mean about having to watch bad films anyway – sometimes I’m just curious about how bad they really are ;-) It is always interesting to see different people have interpreted the same book – enjoy!!

I read this novel some time ago – I am interested to read it again to as you say, “see how many quotes forom the book we use in every day life”. I don’t think I picked up on that the first time.

Do you think a Canadian reading (with looking for commonly used quotes in mind) would be very different form a UK one?

Tricia, Fascinating question! I have no idea what the experience would be like for a Canadian reader. I would love you to read it and let me know how many of the quotes you were aware of.

This one is a favorite of mine, and I also enjoyed a great graphic novel version last year. Have yet to catch this movie but will now despite your warning, I think. Colin Firth thing maybe. :)

Frances, I can’t imagine a graphic novel version. If I see it in the libary I’ll have to pick it up. Hope Colin Firth is enough to distract you from the rest of the movie ;-)

I love dorian gray ,it is so well written and a true classic ,I agree it seeps in to society so much with the people nowadays not wanting to age,like dorian ,you might want try will selfs dorian a modern retelling ,I didn’t see the film it look more style over story to me ,all the best stu

Cool! This was the very first e-book I tried (2003ish) and the narrator’s lovely British accent put me right to sleep. I haven’t revisited it since, but I’m bound to one day!

You just can’t even imagine how happy compliments to Oscar Wilde make me. I’m so glad you liked this book – I thought the purpleness of the prose would aggravate you (it even does me a little). But the story’s excellent. When Oscar Wilde was suing his boyfriend’s father for calling him gay, the prosecutors brought up Dorian Gray and how it was full of objectionable content, and Oscar Wilde had a ball defending it (he did it very well too, it’s fun to read the trial transcripts).

Also, here is the piece of Dorian Gray information that I think is so interesting I feel compelled to comment about it on every review of Dorian Gray that I see: Oscar Wilde said that Basil was what he thought he really was like, Dorian was what he wanted to be like (pre-corruption, one supposes?), and Lord Henry was what the world imagined him to be.

Jenny, I can see why you’d think I might not like it, but I think the amount of wisdom in the text kept me going. It isn’t going to be one of my favourites, but I can see why it is a classic and enjoyed reading it.

Thanks for all the extra Dorian facts – very interesting!

I’m so pleased you enjoyed this. It’s one of my favourites. I know what you mean about the middle – I seem to remember some rambling about classical stuff. Also felt the same about the film. Visually nice, but not a patch on the book.

I loved this book, I love Wilde’s witticisms! He’s so very clever, and each page he wrote was a delight to read. It was wonderful how he turned vanity on its ear in this work.

I saw the movie over 20 years ago as a teenager and I remembered really enjoying the darkness of it — I’d be interested to see how I feel about it now. Of course, it’s really not often that a movie lives up to the book, but I’d like to give it a whirl and read it. I’m a classics fan myself, so I’ll more than likely read it!

Natalie, This movie was only released a year or two ago so you must have seen a different version.Thomas at My Porch mentioned in his comment above how good the old film was – I’ll have to see if I can watch it soon.

I was on an Oscar Wilde reading spree several years ago, and “Dorian” was my favorite of the books I read (I have to double-check to see whether I’ve read them all). I love how smart Oscar Wilde was, both in his writings and during his lifetime.

I’m interested in watching the film, it was the first I heard of the story, and hearing that they made it a lot darker sounds like something worth watching for the comparison. I definitely want to read the book and watch the movie sometime in the not so distant future.

This is a classic that I haven’t had the pleasure to read as of yet. I’m certainly familiar with the story though. I read another review not that long ago on this one that was also favorable. I suppose I should move it up my list of classics that I need to read sooner rather than later.

i read this book and then i really hate see my face in one mirror, the past of the years, it’s terrorific to be old.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.